As Ilango says, JNSAR gives 550 points in a month. i.e, 550*12 = 6600*50=Rs.3,30,000 per lot.
How many in this forum achieved 6600 points or at least 3300 points in a year?. I prefer JNSAR followers like DR, Piyush, Cooldent, Buzz and others to give a honest answer to this.
then let us forget about trading with 2nd lot.what was the actual returns of JNSAR with a single lot with plain strategy without any tinkering? and,how much you or others have achieved in that?
@Sanjay Jaiswalji; From what you explained it means that if I book out any position in put or call after two or three days it will not be considered as reduction in OI? Explaining my question with hypothetical situation: Suppose on 27th of Feb I bought one lot of Put of 5400March series, it will be added in the total OI; on date 29thof Feb I sell it out irrespective of loss or profit would that be considered as reduction of OI in 5400,as the series continues, or an increase in OI as somebody else is buying it. Or no change of status as a created entity is simply changing hands?
Today is 1st march. from today lets calculate for 1 year.. and do trade with only one lot of mini nifty. set the goal to follow JNSAR. keep one seperate account. calculate points. markets are forever try this. LOWEST risk in this trade.
A person with good self-discipline but poor trading method will outperform a person with poor self discipline but the best trading method currently available :P :(
Sir - regarding S4 r u talking about weekly or intra?? Intra means - if it breakes S4 with difficulty means will give false breakout and again touch the S4 Weekly - S4 is always a strong support for positional(many times if it protects i took long and benefitted and few times SL hit.mostly take long if at all mkt @ OS levels + based on long term chart also )i feel grinding here is a warning for bears??? thing is sometimes it will be like today sometimes it will give "clear picture" "timing" is impt.. Today still i don't feel that closing is below 5306 when i observe "something fishy" in the price "will post my blah blah" :) :D
PS :hold on, hold on , hold on 5306... thanks to nifty severe power problem today :P
What I understand from what Ilango has written is that, keeping only JNSAR trades, shows 550 points a month!
I understand that this 550 a month is by trading/ part booking the second lot. Ok, then what is the actual JNSAR returns in a month or year if you trade it with one lot.
Sir - on the way to intra S4 which breakes today 5326.and very sorry forgot to thank you "hats off to your patience" as u "read my comments also" :) "cho" range-kku kuzhappi irukken..donno how many people will scaratch their head today.. it's better to delete my post after u read it sir..pavam ellarum :)
If you simply follow the JNSAR with out any trading, then you are likely to get around 125 points/month. This is based on my own experiences with SAR trading.
There was a time when the BNF only gave 25 points over a period of almost 7 months. In the next 5 it gave 4000 points.
@Nanjil: I guess you are in a mindframe not to accept anything that does not fall in syn with your views.
I guess the only other way would be for master to mention explicitly when it is to be shorted or going long or SL being hit & or putting trailing SL to book profits.
This is against master's principle where he wants us to become independent.
But to say the truth, I never follow JNSAR. I only refer to it. I trade strictly according to what my system says. My system can no way be on par with JNSAR.
Follow it blindly with military precision. Master gains in part booking & an expert at detecting the first signs of reversal (intraday or positional).
there cannot be any concept of returns per month. because few months in rangebound market like all trend following methods i get negative returns from jnsar
Hold on bro! Don’t get emotional as many do. Am sure there is not many here who understands JNSAR better than me. I am putting up my questions with some purpose.
Nifty,
That’s a decent figure and comes closer to the actual. Thanks. I want to know atleast how many reached this decent figure i.e, 125*12=1500 points in a year.
Prabhat,
Don’t waste your time in judging others. You really have no idea about my mind frame :)..If you never follow JNSAR, then my query is not for you.
You are not getting my point. My question is simple. How much it actually generates in a year when approached with a plain vanilla strategy and how much the true followers are achieving?
Cooldent - this hour my target done :) 42..crossover will give moreeeeee but it has to respect 5353 first. then the "bull game may switch on again". let sirupdate his 3 PM TABLE... i can come to some "conclu(fu)sion" :) as usual. now itself i feel 2morow may gap UP??
Nanjil sir - Just a "Q" r u following JNSAR or not??if not then y this Q??? 2nd if u r following what's ur result? often "JNSAR' is "like a political target". there is no need to produce "result" for any "system".. it's mere waste of time.. am sincerely following cam 'many times benefitted and SL hits also". i am not hurting you..if u feel bad "i request sir to erase my comment"
PS : Often comment about 'JNSAR" issue is a irritating one sir pls u too don't
@nanjil, even the plain vanilla strategy wud differ for individual by differences in filters or intra sl. some wud reverse on closing basis only. so maybe only sir wud handle ur query better.
LOL Sudarshan ji has changed his stance 3 times today, first trading range no positions, then shorts and now long :D I follow him closely ever since someone raised a doubt here about his trading style :D
@nanjil If you trying to suggest to people that they should follow JNSAR do it in different words you are amply gifted with them Also as for counting on the plain Vanilla strategy why do not you enlighten us with it as you are very good at backtesting and some of us like us (waste) time trading rather then making such useful studies.As per following any system is individual's choice and Individual karma
Here Nanjil ji is only asking to tell your points you achieved using JNSAR.. In an ideal case you should be achieving as per Sir comment. If not what is the reason you are unable to do so ? I do not feel that Nanjil is trying to comment anything -ve on JNSAR.
s4s - closing inbetween 5343-50. mostly the first one.
Anil -NF atleast should close 5404.. let us see
Nanjil - ji - i don't mean it wrong..but in "all the system" there r "pros and cons" i am not a "systamatic disciplined" player" may he hence i posted immediately to you :) my apologies if it hurts you :(
Even ASR had a couple of OPEN CHALLENGES. I always wonder to whom he is making these open challenges.
I have tracked ASR's Open Challenges. They work 1/10 - a pitiful 10% success rate. I guess he yells "Open Challenges" just to suck in new bees while his HNI clients make the contra trade.
Here's a few good one's from ASR today:
RDX FOR U...................DONT ASK NEWS ,WILL FLASH SOMETHING HOT FOR CUMMINS ON BLOG...Its our First BTST for u.Now at 484....will kiss ?
OPEN CHALLENGE............WATCH PRICE OF CUMMINS @ 3:25...AND TOMOROW MORNING AND AFTEROOOOOOOON !!!!
RED ALERT -Those who bouht CUMMINS @ 480-482 LEVEL....BUY @ 474---473---472.....SELL @ 3:25 AND SALUTE US..........WE SEE 500+ LEVEL IN HR
@ Bhavan - mm.. 6th is the election result or counting it seems. + they may announce petrol hike after that???
really i didn't expect that nifty will close around 5325 today :P i arrived this figure but expected 5343 of EOD closing..donno wat it's gng to reflect tomorow anybody will buy @ open itself hence pulled down??? or more pulling down open itself?? :(
@Moderator tradeinniftyonly (Master Illango) I am a silent observer and use to visit this blog religiously. For the last four months I have observed aggression, Anger, counter attack and trying to show superiority is on high. Please do something to stop all these. Else, it will become like any other forum where all are expert and all know everything.
Please make is again like a city park where we come for daily walk and benefit irrespective of our current position.
Earlier I use to got information on every single line. Everybody was trying to bring some quality news, information, analysis now everybody is trying to show how good he is. I need to explore all comments to find information and unbiased analysis. I will continue to visit this blog in search of knowledge, Your efforts will only help me to zeroing on needful information.
106 comments:
@ Master
Why showing so much resistance after breaking 5306 ?
Pl guide
Quote :
Time decides whom you meet in life.
Your heart decides whom you want in life.
But your BEHAVIOUR decides who will stay in your life.
How many frustrated bears here ? :)
1. Prabhat.
2. ?
3. ?
@ Prahat:
PAtience pays... just wait n watch
@ Hi Prabhat
How do you do ?
As Ilango says, JNSAR gives 550 points in a month. i.e, 550*12 = 6600*50=Rs.3,30,000 per lot.
How many in this forum achieved 6600 points or at least 3300 points in a year?. I prefer JNSAR followers like DR, Piyush, Cooldent, Buzz and others to give a honest answer to this.
If none has achieved above said landmark,why?
@ Manish,
There are "resisting forces at work" at critical levels.
One should mark a SL level and "Sit tight" while the market sorts itself out.
nanji,
if u control emotions,
u can win +6600.
Hitendra,
I didn't ask what to do to win 6600?
I asked who has won 6600 or at least 50% of it-3300??
Sir
GA
@nanjil
Can you answer the same question for yourself?
TRY TO BE HONEST
Sanjay Jaiswal ji / Crorepathi ji,
Thanks for nice explanation about Volume and OI.
Trailing SAR for intraday revised down from 5335 to 5325.
gone
today ns has not broken abv 55ema in 5 min charts..
current price near 5330
OI data plz
contracing triangle apex timewise is near 2.30-3.00pm
will ns make its lows in that time frame??
nanjil
i tink no one had achieved that..........
emotions at some point of time overpower our minds......
Hi Nanjil,
I am a follower of SAR and happily getting 777 points
since 14-12-2011
Follow JNSAR + Kar aitbaar = Daulat beshumar
yogesh,
it seems you are born only to reply to my comment.
@nanjil,
sir also does trading with 2nd lot of jnsar.
that depends on calibre of trader and it wud vary from trader to trader.
red spot pushing nifty hard today
Nanjil
I can give you my trade Log as well,
so Kindly request you not to demoralize....
Piyush,
then let us forget about trading with 2nd lot.what was the actual returns of JNSAR with a single lot with plain strategy without any tinkering? and,how much you or others have achieved in that?
i don't mind wat u say......
it's only up to u
@Sanjay Jaiswalji;
From what you explained it means that if I book out any position in put or call after two or three days it will not be considered as reduction in OI?
Explaining my question with hypothetical situation:
Suppose on 27th of Feb I bought one lot of Put of 5400March series, it will be added in the total OI; on date 29thof Feb I sell it out irrespective of loss or profit would that be considered as reduction of OI in 5400,as the series continues, or an increase in OI as somebody else is buying it. Or no change of status as a created entity is simply changing hands?
S4S
SEE MIDCAP INDEX
@ Nanjil
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0As1OQR9XjwH-dFJ6TEtncmNQSDB0bGV3WVlOQkl4Nmc&hl=en_US#gid=1
This is with one lot only
ilango sir ,extra ordinary accumalation is visible on 5 min charts
ns again moving towards 55ema to fall...ll with more power
@nanjil
i guess u have not completely mentioned sir.
'Even if you remove all the trades of that table and keep only those "JNSAR trades", it is still a healthy "550++points" each month or more.'
this text of sir means the trades he does on tradelog based on various ta studies
@irfan,
i the spreadsheet has restricted access. was it only meant for nanjil??
s4s,
rather than down b/w 2.30/3,
it's up from apex?
For low confidence people.
Today is 1st march. from today lets calculate for 1 year..
and do trade with only one lot of mini nifty.
set the goal to follow JNSAR.
keep one seperate account.
calculate points.
markets are forever try this. LOWEST risk in this trade.
@PS
You can ask for access while opening it
if ns closes abv 5315 today is thr any possibility of a gapup up tomorrow
and upmove till 5370
here my experience -
A person with good self-discipline but poor trading method will outperform a person with poor self discipline but the best trading method currently available :P :(
Sir - regarding S4 r u talking about weekly or intra??
Intra means - if it breakes S4 with difficulty means will give false breakout and again touch the S4
Weekly - S4 is always a strong support for positional(many times if it protects i took long and benefitted and few times SL hit.mostly take long if at all mkt @ OS levels + based on long term chart also )i feel grinding here is a warning for bears??? thing is sometimes it will be like today sometimes it will give "clear picture" "timing" is impt.. Today still i don't feel that closing is below 5306 when i observe "something fishy" in the price "will post my blah blah" :) :D
PS :hold on, hold on , hold on 5306... thanks to nifty severe power problem today :P
Piyush,
What I understand from what Ilango has written is that, keeping only JNSAR trades, shows 550 points a month!
I understand that this 550 a month is by trading/ part booking the second lot. Ok, then what is the actual JNSAR returns in a month or year if you trade it with one lot.
Bhavan,
My HONEST reply later.
bank nifty and nifty again in vicinity of 55ema in 5min
charts..last attempt by bulls
@ Prabhat:
OK, now I am a frustrated bear too ;(
Sir - on the way to intra S4 which breakes today 5326.and very sorry forgot to thank you "hats off to your patience" as u "read my comments also" :) "cho" range-kku kuzhappi irukken..donno how many people will scaratch their head today.. it's better to delete my post after u read it sir..pavam ellarum :)
@nanji,
If you simply follow the JNSAR with out any trading, then you are likely to get around 125 points/month. This is based on my own experiences with SAR trading.
There was a time when the BNF only gave 25 points over a period of almost 7 months. In the next 5 it gave 4000 points.
@Irfan: Same as PS. restricted access..
@Nanjil: I guess you are in a mindframe not to accept
anything that does not fall in syn with your views.
I guess the only other way would be for master to mention
explicitly when it is to be shorted or going long or SL
being hit & or putting trailing SL to book profits.
This is against master's principle where he wants us to
become independent.
But to say the truth, I never follow JNSAR. I only refer
to it. I trade strictly according to what my system
says. My system can no way be on par with JNSAR.
Follow it blindly with military precision. Master gains in
part booking & an expert at detecting the first signs
of reversal (intraday or positional).
intraday SL hit.
If 26 is taken out 5342 hit this hour itself
why bears are frustrated ? Didn't you receive full weekly meal on single day (150 points fall)
@Master: Below what levels for closure today should we carry
forwards our shorts made today @5345 levels?
@ Irfan
Thanks for sharing.
Sharing for growing together !!!!!!!!!
@nanjil,
there cannot be any concept of returns per month.
because few months in rangebound market like all
trend following methods i get negative returns
from jnsar
Sis
a close above Dlema?
Irfan,
Hold on bro! Don’t get emotional as many do. Am sure there is not many here who understands JNSAR better than me. I am putting up my questions with some purpose.
Nifty,
That’s a decent figure and comes closer to the actual. Thanks. I want to know atleast how many reached this decent figure i.e, 125*12=1500 points in a year.
Prabhat,
Don’t waste your time in judging others. You really have no idea about my mind frame :)..If you never follow JNSAR, then my query is not for you.
@Nanjil,
I am fairly new to JNSAR when compared to stalwarts like you and DR sir.
By the way, what is the point you are coming to? :) Am I missing something?
me hungri stilll .... Ye dil bhi kambhakt zid pe ada hain ya hume sab kuch chahiye ya kuch nahin .... Ha ha ha ha
@ Prabhat,
Since the shorts were created @ 5345NS and you want to make it positional, keep 5351(Intra High) as SL as well as a close above 5340 DLEma.
I had suggested a trailing SAR @ 5325 for "Intraday".
Piyush,
You are not getting my point. My question is simple. How much it actually generates in a year when approached with a plain vanilla strategy and how much the true followers are achieving?
@Nanjil
If you understand any SAR then there should be
no more questioning?
SAR is just a trading method.
other 2 thing required for result is
money management and discipline
think of that......
Another attack @ DLEma:5340+
Cooldent - this hour my target done :) 42..crossover will give moreeeeee but it has to respect 5353 first. then the "bull game may switch on again". let sirupdate his 3 PM TABLE... i can come to some "conclu(fu)sion" :) as usual. now itself i feel 2morow may gap UP??
DR-ji - bring the "calf's " mother now :D
MAM,
please specify
if it breakes S4 with difficulty means will give false breakout .
thanks
last 30min
Nanjil sir - Just a "Q" r u following JNSAR or not??if not then y this Q??? 2nd if u r following what's ur result? often "JNSAR' is "like a political target". there is no need to produce "result" for any "system".. it's mere waste of time.. am sincerely following cam 'many times benefitted and SL hits also". i am not hurting you..if u feel bad "i request sir to erase my comment"
PS : Often comment about 'JNSAR" issue is a irritating one sir pls u too don't
@nanjil,
even the plain vanilla strategy wud differ for individual by differences in filters or intra sl.
some wud reverse on closing basis only.
so maybe only sir wud handle ur query better.
madam ji,
i also use CAM's as on of my
guidelines for long/short.
Sir,
3 pm update pl.
3.00PM TT & Chart updated.
Closed above HLEma & HEma.
Now for a close above DLEma.
@sujatha
5415-20 NF...a restricted zone...
Sujatha,
no sir business with me pls..do you think am I putting here my Qs in such a way to damage JNSAR’s reputation?
IS it going to be long tailed Bulkowski's Opening Black Marubozu
thepatternsite.com/OpenBlkMaru.html
@Ilango
Aggressive positional longs at DLEMA??????????
LOL Sudarshan ji has changed his stance 3 times today, first trading range no positions, then shorts and now long :D I follow him closely ever since someone raised a doubt here about his trading style :D
@Nanjil
Suspense se parda uthao!
sujatha mam..ur closing levels plz
@Sujatha
if closed above 5350-55 this hour, i am getting TGT's 5500/50...if at all PT allows...
closing below 5330 not good for bulls...
DEAR SIR,
IF CLOSE ABOVE DLEMA THAN SHOULD CUT THE SHORT POS.
Sir,
C/F the shorts.
Is that fine ?
When will the petrol price increase?
I am expecting close below 5300 tmrw.
@nanjil
If you trying to suggest to people that they should follow
JNSAR do it in different words you are amply gifted with them
Also as for counting on the plain Vanilla strategy why do not you enlighten us with it as you are very good at backtesting and some of us like us (waste) time trading rather then making such useful studies.As per following any system is individual's choice and Individual karma
Here Nanjil ji is only asking to tell your points you achieved using JNSAR..
In an ideal case you should be achieving as per Sir comment. If not what is the reason you are unable to do so ? I do not feel that Nanjil is trying to comment anything -ve on JNSAR.
@ Indus,
I'm not comfortable with such Overnight longs.
"Intraday opportunities" are good besides the positional shorts.
s4s - closing inbetween 5343-50. mostly the first one.
Anil -NF atleast should close 5404.. let us see
Nanjil - ji - i don't mean it wrong..but in "all the system" there r "pros and cons"
i am not a "systamatic disciplined" player" may he hence i posted immediately to you :)
my apologies if it hurts you :(
@Anil
Agar bichme to kya?
close above DLEMA ?
Sanjayji,
probable close price?
@Sujatha time to change uniform I feel so till election results?
@Ilango
Thank you.....could u let me know tomorrow's developing
JNSAR? or is it too premature?
@AJ,
Good one on that Sukhani.
Even ASR had a couple of OPEN CHALLENGES.
I always wonder to whom he is making these
open challenges.
I have tracked ASR's Open Challenges. They
work 1/10 - a pitiful 10% success rate.
I guess he yells "Open Challenges" just to
suck in new bees while his HNI clients make
the contra trade.
Here's a few good one's from ASR today:
RDX FOR U...................DONT ASK NEWS ,WILL FLASH SOMETHING HOT FOR CUMMINS ON BLOG...Its our First BTST for u.Now at 484....will kiss ?
OPEN CHALLENGE............WATCH PRICE OF CUMMINS @ 3:25...AND TOMOROW MORNING AND AFTEROOOOOOOON !!!!
RED ALERT -Those who bouht CUMMINS @ 480-482 LEVEL....BUY @ 474---473---472.....SELL @ 3:25 AND SALUTE US..........WE SEE 500+ LEVEL IN HR
today more nifty premium reduced.
@Bhavan
for me if bichme, then as per my system its a
still 'PT's game...
For those who are in a dilema that if NS will close above or below DLEMA;
NS adjusted close could come around 5339.50, maybe, said maybe just at or below DLEMA (Margin of error 1 points max)
Thanks & Regards
@ Indus,
It is always on the chart: 5429.
@Hitendra atCMP 5331 arond 5340+/-1
closing price +-2 5340
thankx sanjay sir...
@sis,
Bull biryani??
Thanks Sanjayji & Bhavan.
@Irfan,
I would be obliged if you could grant access to me too. Requested.
@ Indus,
It is always in the TT: 5429.(From 10.00AM)
@Master
Nifty closed below 34 minute EMA at 5330 too.
@ Bhavan - mm.. 6th is the election result or counting it seems. + they may announce petrol hike after that???
really i didn't expect that nifty will close around 5325 today :P i arrived this figure but expected 5343 of EOD closing..donno wat it's gng to reflect tomorow anybody will buy @ open itself hence pulled down??? or more pulling down open itself?? :(
And here is the price of Cummins futures today:
Day high: 487.50
Closing price: 471.50
Day low: 464
Price at 3:25 PM: 472.05
ASR's client bought cummins @ 484 and I wonder
when they bailed out.
The only person to SALUTE ASR must be his HNI clients.
@nifty
I guess you mention about him before
"It is far easy to follow price than a person" :D
@irfan,
Request send, kindly accept.
@ Sanjay bhai
Tumhara bhi jawaab nahi
5339.75.
@Nanjil: I do not know you from now on. You have very high
temper & agressive. I stay away from such people.
My last word to you: Sorry & bye forever.
@Moderator tradeinniftyonly (Master Illango)
I am a silent observer and use to visit this blog religiously.
For the last four months I have observed aggression,
Anger, counter attack and trying to show superiority is
on high.
Please do something to stop all these. Else, it will
become like any other forum where all are expert and all
know everything.
Please make is again like a city park where we come for daily
walk and benefit irrespective of our current position.
Earlier I use to got information on every single line. Everybody
was trying to bring some quality news, information, analysis
now everybody is trying to show how good he is. I need
to explore all comments to find information and unbiased
analysis.
I will continue to visit this blog in search of knowledge,
Your efforts will only help me to zeroing on needful information.
Post a Comment