JNSAR is a stop & reverse method..mechanical in nature and you stay in a trade all the time. However, once you are experienced, using the Tech.table, you would spot those sideways periods when Nifty closes below DHEma during uptrend or above DLEma during downtrend and adopt a trading strategy by using JNSAR as a pivot and keep part booking it near DHEma & DLEma.
Elliott wave study is highly subjective (because each sees the wave differently and there is no definition for what is a wave), though over a period of exposure you can adopt more objectivity to it. EW helps you to sell even when the trend is firm & strong as per various technical parameters and it also helps you to buy when selling frenzy is on and panic all around.
A combination may be adopted where in EW may be used for profit booking at critical reversal points. You must possess rich experience in your choice of using these methods at various points. EW helped us to spot 5935-65 resistances along with a simple price study and sJNSAR confirmed it with a sell @ 5855 and EW pointed out a bottoming near 5465 and even helped with the small trading moves & JNSAR is yet to confirm it...There could be small whipsaws.
As your example pointed out, TataMotors was a buy above 1172 as per EW and buy above 1186 as per JNSAR. If you are confident of your EW study, you would go long above 1177 and look out for an additional confirmation from the other method(JNSAR). One method should be the primary decision makin g basis and the others should come in as secondary confirmatory ones. There is absolutely no conflict here. One will be lagging and one will be leading as we have in "Stochastics and Macd combo" where in Stochastics(Lead Indicator) leads and Macd(Trend indicator) lags. It is a combination of aggressive & conservative approach. This kind of combination methods improve the returns as long as you keep them simple and in their repective places-primary, secondary.
It need not get more complicated. If one is not able to make money using these, then the fault lies with the individuals emotion-handling capability, belief-in self. One need to work on them.
Bob Prechtor who won decades ago trading in options using EW gives a lot of credit to his "military experience" where orders are obeyed without questions. When you start believing in your systems in that military fashion after having accepted it whole heartedly, you have started an automated mechanism within you which is capable of making money consistently. Once the money starts pouring in, your "ego" is likely to interfere - beware of it and keep it in check or throw it away when trading. Distractions has always been the bane of traders. Take a cue from Rajinikanth, take your laptop and go to a cave in a mountain...if that is what will solve your problem. But then, if you start running, then even an insect in the cave will distract you. Stay where you are but set your mind into equilibrium.

