Friday, August 27, 2010

Nifty Intraday Update-I

45 comments:

Unknown said...

GM Sir & frnds...

Neha said...

Finally the 50 min is now moving lower n away from 100 min... while 200 min is above both 50 n 100 min... so the downside shud continue fr now...

mo h said...

@ nifty
i think bipin had told,
1 lot book at swing advantage,
2nd lot, SAR reversal at SAR,
so, he would hav been in the otherside position to take advantage.
since sar is always in position.

the sharp jumps in one direction in disadvantage gets averaged out, since any sar system is for longer terms ...

if we feed the back data we may get an idea into what may happen under different circumstance.

this is apart from the inherent risk factor thats there in any system.

nifty said...

@Bipin

I think there is a serious flaw with your approach.

Here's my take on that.

i. You establish long positions in 2 Lot (Mini Nifty/Nifty) at Nifty SAR of maybe 5475 whatever.

ii. Price moves higher by 50-75 points and you book profit with 1 lot.

iii. Price goes down to your entry price and maybe even lower than your cost. You say you Stop out at cost on your 2nd lot. Now you don't have either a Long or Short Position.

iv. What if now the price tends lower but not low enough to reverse the trades into a Short position as per the system. When do you re-establish your Long positions ?

iv. And God Forbid, what if there is a Sharp price reversal to knock out the stops and then the price breaks out to the upside and sustains for a very long period of time. Like 500-750 Nifty points ?

I thought the idea behind the SAR system was that you are "Always in a trade". With your approach, when the market trends you may end up with no trades at all.

My intention is not to criticize you but to determine the best SAR trading system.

nifty said...

@mok

From what I read Bipin clearly indicates trailing Stop Loss at Cost for his 2nd Lot. I am copying and pasting here.

==============================================================================
I trade always two lots and enter into trade as per the SAR levels.....For profit booking I look at the price movement and book as and when I feel comfortable for one lot and trail stop loss to the entry price for the 2nd lot soasto protect the capital.
==============================================================================

mo h said...

@ nifty,
no problem :)
i think he means [though it will be ideal for us to hear from him]
that he books 1st lot at a swing high to lock a profit when he sees one,
and carries the 2nd lot to be sar ed at sar level,
and in case if sar gives a loss, he would have already gained at the 1st lot which will avg into profit.
this is how i understood his writing.

but your analysis is for the good only, since only such sharp analysis can make the system better.

DCStrader said...

again near the yesterdays Resistance 5485-90.
5490 -5435 think this is the range which were side it breaks can mk newer intermidiate high or low respt.

Lalit said...

whipsaw at JNSAR and overnight gap up or gapdown is main concern to this trading method, hope more we interact we will come out with still more fine tuned method with guidence from sir

mo h said...

@ lalit, yes ...
think we can do something like, use sir's excel table where we find the hourly nifty spot rates.
and try it out in back testing. [or with any broker terminal data]
since it is positional, we need to avoid the intraday type testing, and should test if with positional entry concept.

bipin said...

yes........

Mok is right what I want to say. Booking profit for 1st lot and trail sl for the 2nd at entry level or any other level near to SAR.

Now suppose we don't put this sl at even entry level and price goes against our expectations, we will have to lose. What I have learned that protection of capital with the help of sl is the main rule which one has to follow with discipline. The only thing is to watch price movement carefully..........and if we learnt how to protect capital with the help of such various tools, market will automatically gives returns. And SAR guides us in this connection.

bipin said...

@Lalit,

As regards whipsaw, I can say that in case of SAR system, the effects of whipsaws are less and bearable. And after completion of certain number of whipsaws, a large break out gives us good returns.

Lalit said...

@ mok,,, till further clarity i traded
short below JNSAR with suitable stop loss for 15/20 pts gain could do 3 times since yesterday

Anil said...

@all

A huge put writing at open seems, we are going to cross 5500 today.

mo h said...

@ bipin, i also think one gapup will get nullified by another gapdown,

@ lalit, :) thats nice ...
the established support wud act as resistance now 5485 range.
and the 5460 5450 5440 5415 5385 are established series of supports anyway ...
we can watch for their breaks.

Bhavan said...

some time back it was pointed out by somebody the relation btwn tatasteel and nifty going by that stds we still have a upmove

nifty said...

My finding has been that this has been a dreadful year for the Nifty SAR trading systems. They range from -50 to +100 points/month. Last year it was close to +100 to +250 points/month.

The Bank Nifty has been doing reasonably good. This late surge has been immensely helpful. This year the BNF has averaged around +250 to +500 points/month, the same as last year.

Bhavan said...

since nifty is approaching one of the SAR levels 5498 does this mean that we should initiate longs ifthose levels are touched?

mo h said...

as per my level with filter added, i would sar NF at 5503
for Long.
I will take 2 lots,
i suggest papertrade on this for sometime..

2010 has been bad for many trade systems, except few methods.
but reasonable returns are still there.

Bhavan said...

@MOK or @NIFTY please explain that if nifty crosses 5498 todays SAR levels we can go long ?

bipin said...

@ Mok,
you are right...one gap up is nullified by another gapdown......but that is called whipsaw...
and it is all depends upon how you derive SAR. Moreover in case of SAR system, positional trades get much benefits rathar than intra day. Of course by watching SAR levels carefully one can also earn intra day.......but in that case the breach of SAR must be with volume and conviction....

Look at TA table for daily and 5LowEMA levels and if you consider it as SAR.......and see how it has functioned so far.....very less whipsaws are there......

mo h said...

@ bhavan,
NF JNsar is 5494, and i add 9 points filter to that to avoid whipsaw and failures,
so i would book the short and go long at 5503 crossing,

suggest you start marking up a papertrade.
sir is finetuning the system.
soon he would elaborate on our queries,
and this post is going to help get all the answers.

for me 5503 NFuture level to go long
2lots
if reaches 5578 i will part book one lot.

if fails and falls,
i will partbook 1 lot of the 2 lot short at 5440

Of this and that said...

My actual experience with JN.SAR. I took a long at 5444 when JN.SAR was 5438 with two lots. I booked out one lot at 5530 (96 points) and the second lot at 5506(62 points) when Sir gave call to reverse position at 5511.Now average gain is 96+62/2=79 points. Now if today's JN.SAR gets triggered at 5498, I will go long or wait till Monday for a close above 5498 to go long. In a month if one gets 2-3 trades of average 80 points, it is good going. Implementing a system actually is more important especially when advise comes from a master who has been breathing the market since 1992. Thanks Ilango Sir.

mo h said...

@ bipin, yes i concur with your thoughts...

intraday will need a much lesser timeframe sar to give us the move advantage.

mo h said...

@ of this and that,
thats the kind of partbooking we were experimenting.
and, in our findings the results were encouraging.
the major advantage in positional is lesser trade, and better control, since we are able to decide early.

Bhavan said...

@mok again bothering you but from the later part of your ans. it means that if it fails to go up after buying we maitain a SL at the SAR down level and go short for both the lots after booking loss in the initial position

nifty said...

Bhavan,

If you follow the system religiously (no exceptions to any of the signals) then you should be making reasonable profits of 100 to 200 points a month. Yes I am going to be Long at 5498 NS. But it is still 20 points away.

Disclosure: I also trade stocks as well. I am holding Short positions only.

mo h said...

@ bhavan,
how we tested is:
1.. Have the JNsar level,
2.. Have a filter band around it for avoiding the whipsaws.
3.. It is positional, but for taking advantage of the best entry level, the entries done on intralevels.
4.. Only first entry done,
5.. Entry with 2 lots
6.. 1 lot for partbooking at swing level. [of taking 50 something points when reached]
7.. 2nd lot maintained till we get to JNsar again.
8.. at SAR ing we will square and enter another 2 lots.
9.. if position goes wrong we would maintain position till sar is reached
[since that is the sar concept, of always in position]
10.. if second signal in same direction is raised, we ignore it,
we do not add to position..

we will discuss here among us and improve it further.
since each of us have valuable additions and corrections.
:)

Bhavan said...

@mok &@nifty thanks for the response but coming to more precise figures for a better understanging todays JNSAR levels in the premarket tables are 5498 and on the shorter side 5483 for a person entering today can take a long after 5498 is crossed in NS then wait for the profit as per his capacity and patience or till the next level by sir is generated but if due any false breakout or any reason the desired move doesnot take place he should exit and reverse @ 5483 the other level mentioned

Of this and that said...

Yes u r right mok and thanks for your reply.

mo h said...

@ bhavan, yes bhavan, in the event of a failure.
higher one is for going Long, lower one is for going Short,
since we are in Short now, we would take the higher one to go Long.

@ of this and that
thanks :)

mo h said...

sir has added the filter to JNsar.

mo h said...

sorry, sir, has NOT put filter,
i think he has put the Short entered level, for records

Unknown said...

Thanks Mok & sir for your labour on JNSAR....

here, how about the idea of booking both at a good swing and enter again at the dynamic sar available at that time.....plz pardon if am sounding silly :)

regards

Of this and that said...

@bhavan if going long at 5498 today i will keep a stop loss aggressively at yesterday's JN.SAR of 5483 and if close is above 5490 i would carry the position for Monday. The first time one takes a trade one always needs to take an aggressive stop loss and better method is to take Wednesday's JN.SAR as stop loss. This way loss will be just 15 points, worth the risk if u see the upside.

Unknown said...

NS is solidy above pivot and making sure to stay above hour ema.

and NF above POC strongly and seeking to get past VAH.

mo h said...

@ Ka,
:) why not :D
after all one trades for making money,
it would be a nice swing return, like a fixed tgt booking.

only, we will not be capturing the big moves.

nifty said...

@mok

Your strategy sounds reasonable enough. The only upgrade that I might look for is to somehow link the Part booking levels to India Vix. For instance, a range of Vix 15 to 20 might correspond to 50 to 75 points and so on.

@Bhavan,

To protect against sharp intraday reversals, one could keep a SL of 0.60% to 0.75% (about 35 to 45 Nifty points) and wait for re-entry

mo h said...

@ nifty,
your additions carry good value addition,
i put +50 to 75 and minus 50 as my calculated average swing values from midpoint of nifty future in past 2 years.
:)
Vix does not always get met, its an approximation.
you can consider fibo or pivot values instead.
that has some good statistics returns.

Bose said...

Dear mok

If you can please clarify the queries listed below, it would be nice:

1. What is the maximum loss in a trade that one would incur

2. What are the maximum whipsaws one has to undertake before a trend emerges. Also, what is the "cumulative" loss for the whipsaw trades

3. Since there is only one SAR level for the day and we have to carry over our position overnight and trade according to next day's SAR, the query is:

What is the maximum number of points that the Nifty goes above / below on the opposite side of JNSAR level on any day. Is it 30 points, 40 points or more.

For example, if the JNSAR + Filter for today is 5503. We take a long position at 5503. Now after going upto 5520, Nifty reverses and goes BELOW JNSAR - Filter. How many points (maximum)has the Nifty fallen to in backtesting.

Vice versa for short positions.

The above queries I have because it will help to know how much loss one would have to take and will help in position sizing. Profits can come later :)

Hope I have been express my thoughts clearly. If not, please let me know.

Regards
Bose

Bhavan said...

THANKS A LOT FOR ALL THE HELP PROVIDED BY EVERYBOY ON THE SUBJECT

Neha said...

12L 5400 puts sold today... n max selling on call side is at 5700 strike..mkt still bullish.

Ilango said...

NEW POST DONE.

mo h said...

@ bose,
these queries need proper details to be answered.
i think you need to wait for sir finalizing the details and present fine details.
since a casual answer will not fulfill
:)
but the results are encouraging.

Lalit said...

my trading plan if NC crosses 5498, buy 3lots of mininifty, trade one lot for 15-20 points keeping entry point as SL for one lot, if by chance mkt touches 5550 offload 2 lots and last one lot will be allowed to reverse at next JNSAR but when trade is to be reverse i will take position of 3 lots of reverse position.... coments from blogmates welcome

nifty said...

@Bose

For position sizing, I just trade for the amount of capital that I have. So for a capital of Rs 1 lakh, if you follow my methodology, then you would trade 1 Mini Nifty. I do not leverage at all. This way I need not worry about margin calls etc.

About 2-3 days back, I had requested Mr Ilango to provide with 2 JNSAR, namely the SAR to go Long called the JNSAR-Long and the SAR to go Short, called the JNSAR-Short. He had suggested that my request will be looked into and back tested before implementing such a system. If such a system arrives, then one need not worry about intraday reversals as the JNSAR-Long and JNSAR-Short to take care of it. Until then, I guess we will have to go with Of this and That's suggestion of using the previous day's JNSAR. It seems like the most reasonable plan.

Post a Comment

Elliot's Impulse waves.(Part-5)

IMPULSE WAVES :- The Basics Waves that move the market in the direction of its main trend either up or down are called Impulse waves. 1....