It captures almost all of the "Big moves" but its utility during "indecisive/ sideways" markets are limited. It helped to identify the "tug of war point" in yesterday's move and it was suggested that once it moves past 5981, it will gather strength.
Dinesh Rishi has offered some additional strategies to be employed while using these methods-20 point leeway.
My table will continue to show the simple approach but you must improvise on it by using the "intraday levels" as well as "Intraday TA" too.
If you want to capture big moves of 600+ points in a single trade, please be willing to let go off 100 points in a few trades too. Mitigate this by active trading based on sideways market's ranges.
Lastly, some would like to boast of their predictions and some would naively open their heart and share their observations without holding back. Don't pick holes in their observations for it is difficult to convey it all in a fast changing markets. Be grateful to their time & only encourage their sharing nature.
51 comments:
Good Morning Ilango Sir and Friends
Nifty daily analysis: CTRL + CLICK HERE
Thank you
Good Morning all!
Good Morning Ilango Sir, San and RM
GM Prabakar
Good Morning Ilango sir and all friends...
SGX nifty currently trading at 6053.. my layman doubt is will the market react to the FII ban by sebi yesterday?
Dear Ilango Sir,
Good Morning.
In the Buy/sell column,For shorts u have used -ve sign(for 25-08-2010).think for yesterday new short@5981,you please keep -ve sign instead of +ve sign.
think Still you are keeping shorts.think you reverse the trade i.e close shorts and buy 2 lots,if nifty closes@6014.99979.I calculated by including +0.3% filter.Please correct me,if I am wrong.
good morning,seniors..
jnsar with +0.3% filter is 6014.9979.I mistakenly typed as 6014.99979.
Ilango Sir and Seniors,
If my comment is wrong,Please correct me.So I can learn from your advice.
Sir
Either it has to be short at 5981 or long at 6014,
It cant be long 5981
Kindly clarify
======
Good morning Ilango Sir and all
======
====
Sir,
Yesterday I shorted NF @ 5980 NS. Today's JNSAR is 5994. Due to today gapup opening, missed to close shorts and go long. In this circumstances, what can I do Sir? Still I am holding my shorts.
====
GM.... Sir and friends..
chart will post later....
Discover new indicator,,, lets see it will work or not..
i will update here ,, for reversal..
Now indicator showing some reversal.. lets see..
please somebody answer my query, thanks in advance
Asian electronics, is a stock listed on both the exchanges.
its promoter holding is showing as zero, on bseindia.com
1. is it possible that a company is listed & promoter holding is zero.
2. What are the important & vital conclusions to be made of this event, that promoter holding is zero .
3. Stock has fallen from a high of 550 kind of levels to 24, is it worth taking a risk.
4. Is, the promoter holding only can be considered as a reason for not taking such risks.
5. Is it a concern that indices are close to life time high, & stock is close to its 52 week ( not a lifetime ) low.
6. Is it worth buying a share @ slightly lower prices, or averaging ( i know nobody advises averaging, but asking for such low promoter holding stocks only ) it on further lower levels.
7.This stock has been falling since last 13 months, and all 13 months, it has been making lower lows & lower highs ?
8. DOes anybody know, any such stock in which either a.- promoter holding is close to zero 2. - stocks is falling since a very reasonable time. B coz, i know, once other such stock, i.e. rei agro, falling, since last 12 months, again making ll & lh on monthly scale.
9. What s the way to track such companies, i.e. how can we track, that if in a particular stock, promoter holding is falling considerably, over a given period of time.
10. In the same manner, if lower promoter holding, can be considered as a reason to take caution to enter a stock, Can we consider a high FII holding as a valid reason to enter any stock.
I know, this is like, asking for too much but then i also know, that there are no. of experienced, sincere & knowledgable trader over here, which wud take pleasure to answer my query. Also, answers to my query can act as good learning lessons for the new bies.
thanks, regards
P.S. - I invite, views & comments from all intellectual, smart & experienced trader, available here at JN , to kindly guide us in the same regards
Dear Ilango Sir,
Should the trade be reversed to long at 6080 or is it just stoploss sir?
Gm Illango Sir & all,
Update on Nf option Hedging Strategy
Sold 5700 Ce @ 245-369=-124
Sold 6000 Pe @ 210-126=84
Bought Nf @ 5900-6033=133
Total MTM- -124+84+133=93 points
Target 200 points in 10-15 days
Good Morning Sir and Warriors
When market declined and breached JNSAR 5981, long trade has been closed and short trade has been entered into. Market then decline only to 5964 and again got support therefrom and bounce back and crossed JNSAR again from below and hence long should be taken at that level, I had taken long after 20 points i.e. at 6001. Because above JNSAR (5981) trend is upward........
This is what I have done.....now I will watch today's JNSAR and also intends to book partially inbetween.
-arpit345
Good morning Sir and all :)
Sir - Good going "fast moves" in Gartley :)
My sincere apologies to sarvesh, arivunambi and Ganesh, if hurt because of my "opinion". Assure you that "will avoid in future".
Hi manu - Check mail.. your favourite stock details sent. Mint money and transfer some of your profit to my a/c :D
gd morning @ all i think no body is properly understand JNSAR
===
Ilango Sir,
Where can I close my shorts (Shorts at 5980 NS)? and go Long? Please guide me
====
yeah..where to put end to last short trade now??? rule is to minimise loss...so,,shud we wait or shud we book here only?
Hi arpitg345 ,
As per Ilango sir's jnsar,I think we dont reverse
the new trade on the same day.
Please correct me,If I am wrong.
Looks like arpit got it right :)
It looks like JNSAR should be followed on EOD basis rather than intra.
@ Illango Sir,
Two days back you had posted 5932/5846/5774 as a possible 4th.
Considering today's post of Ascending triangle does the previous view still valid ?
thanks
Dear Arpit
you are correct,The long trade can be at 6014( .3% )
0r around 6000(the EXPECTED sar for next day), But to go
long at 5981 is not clear.
That is why i have requested sir to clarify,However ,i agree
10-15 pts here or there doesnt matter but rationale to go long at 5981 needs to be understood
yeh thats what was told..and now what to do in this situation when last trade is open and we have a gap up ..shud we keep it or what???? SIR, PLEASE CLARIFY
no its not about ging long or not....its about what to be done that day if sar hits and
position comes into a loss ..what then??
shud we close it that day only or carry it
===
Hi Bizagra!Are you having having yesterdays NF shorts?
====
Nifty intraday update: CTRL + CLICK HERE
According to ORB in the morning nifty gave a buy .... adn still 6080 as the SL is in Place... We may retrace form 6095-6105 ... to again 6040-6060
http://tradeinniftyonly.blogspot.com/2010/09/jnsar-stop-and-reverse-trading-method.html#comments
says
Step:2: If after triggering a reversal trade @ 5468 and markets fall again, you do not change the trade on the same day as JNSAR is done only once a day but do so only the next day based on next day's JNSAR. (Risk averse could have a Stop loss in extreme choppiness but the essence of JNSAR is to keep the trade once triggered and manage it the next day only. If and when such extremes take place, I'll be around to alert you.This has not happened in the last 3 years).
a call from ilango sir wud be very valuable here after 100 points gone almost
Dear Sir Ilango,
Day before yesterday, I had sent you a mail with various probabilities in which I was looking for a probable 3rd wave of 5th wave as one of the probability.
Isn't this looking like it?
Regards,
Mehul
sir & family
Gm..
@suj
Replied..thnx
New chart updated
Nifty intraday update: CTRL + CLICK HERE
Hold on Guys market not going to end in 1 day
Be patience & hold shorts,no one is perfect,if a system
gives 600 points in 15 days Y u arguing it if it takes
only 100 point sfrom u,stillposition opened & market not
closed yet.
right musti ... But just before two days sir had given as small indication that the rally will mature above 6080... Lets see if it holds today....
I would be going short at these levels .... irrespective of any thing ... and wait for monday
@San, please post RIL chart update also..thx in advance.
Yesterday I have given
30 Sep 10, 09:03
Rishi: SAR BN 12150 Nifty 5950 (added filter bit more due to expiry day)
and logic behind 20/50 point SL (nifty/BN) is
if we are again above SAR system says we must be long
Enough has been said about following "JNSAR".
Even while stating that "JNSAR" has been hit @ 5981 yesterday, I suggested to "Use your imagination and sell @ higher levels. That would be to your advantage. And our levels came well yesterday.
Even if you have shorted @ 5981, today's JNSAR+ filter would be 5994+18=6012. A gap up, you reverse your trade @ 6040(spot) or 6050NF.And even book in one lot with 50+ points.
Be involved in your trades. Don't wait for instructions on each trade.
@ Musti , Powertrade: U r right... one must have patience... unluckily, maybe some like me have just entered a new position with JNSAR and have not captured the first 600 points... so are starting with a loss. hence, the anxiety!
Sir
6080 SLR
I am receiving one or two mail daily from friends having
Yahoo IDs giving some links,
On confirming they say they did not sent
it seems their IDs are hacked
Please change you password if you are having Yahoo ID
I too wait for 6095 level for shorts,but for intra
with sl 6105.Lets see
Is BN target achieved, can we go short here?
NEW POST DONE.
Sold 2 6094 sl 6105.
Yes, I have taken long at 6001 considering JNSAR of the day when traded with the intention to watch JNSAR next day. Today market opened in gap up. But if it open in gap down and breached today's JNSAR, I would have closed my long trade again and reverse my trade. Such type of whipsaws are natural and one has to face them. in any case we cannot avoid whipsaws, but with the help of SAR method the effects of whipsaws can be minimised and made bearable sothat ultimate result will remain in positive figure of profits.
-arpitg345
@NiftySparks
I was the one who suggested a Short Position in BNF. The entry point was lucrative if the markets reversed from 6074 top. Yes, I got stopped out. But my loss was 12373-12402 = 29 points. No big deal here. Remember yesterday I had made 300 points in BNF longs. So what if I give a little of it.
Others might already know that I have been positionally long in a lot of stocks. Jindal Steel, Tata Motors, Hindalco, etc. Even with this positional, I have been trading JSPL and make money as it has been ridiculously rangebound.
Good Morning Ilango sir and all
Post a Comment